Cape Cod home in Montauk, NY
Set in Montauk, NY, this Cape Cod home provides 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms across 1,431 square feet. Notable features include lake / river / water view and swimming pool.
| Price | $2,300,000 |
|---|
| Beds | 2 |
|---|
| Baths | 2 |
|---|
| Sqft | 1431 |
|---|
| Architectural style | Cape Cod (86% match) |
|---|
| Address | 15 Elm Lane, Montauk, NY 11954 |
|---|
Why buy this home
- Confirmed Cape Cod architecture, matched from the listing photos by Enzo's vision model.
- Features: lake / river / water view, swimming pool.
- Links directly to the original source listing on Trulia.
Is this a good buy?
Priced below comparable homes.
- At $2.3M, this home is 23% below the $3M median for 174 similar Cape Cod homes in Montauk, NY.
- That works out to $1607 per square foot, 1% above the $1590 comparable rate.
- On the market 61 days, longer than usual here, so the seller may be open to offers.
| This home | $2,300,000 |
|---|
| Cape Cod median in Montauk, NY | $2,975,000 (174 homes) |
|---|
| Price per sq ft | $1,607 vs. $1,590 comps median |
|---|
Enzo's reads public listing data and links to the original source. Confirm condition, HOA, taxes and fees there. This is a signal, not advice.
What it costs to own
Estimated at $16,749/month with 20% down at a 7.28% 30-year fixed rate. You would need about $717,800 in gross annual income to keep housing within a 28% ratio.
| Mortgage (P&I) | $12,590/mo |
|---|
| Property tax (new-buyer reassessed rate) | $3,297/mo |
|---|
| Homeowners insurance | $863/mo |
|---|
| Total monthly | $16,749/mo |
|---|
| Down payment (20%) | $460,000 |
|---|
| Income needed | $717,800/yr |
|---|
A signal to compare homes, not financial advice or a loan offer.
Financial outlook (modeled)
Enzo's grades this home B- (65 out of 100) over a 5-year hold, from a Monte-Carlo of local home-price dynamics and the interest-rate path versus renting.
| Grade | B- (65/100) |
|---|
| Beats renting in | 16% of modeled paths |
|---|
| Modeled 5-yr equity (median) | $1,185,027 |
|---|
| Range (10th to 90th pct) | $719,976 to $1,746,542 |
|---|
A probabilistic model built on public data (Zillow ZHVI, FRED rates), not a guarantee or financial advice. Local price dynamics are pooled toward US where local data is thin.
Local home values
Typical home values in United States have risen about 20% over the past 5 years (+1% in the last year), per the Zillow Home Value Index. This reflects the national market, not this specific home.
View this home on Trulia